Wednesday, November 17, 2021

Professional Development (aka "waste of time") for teachers

 We all hear it from all of our teacher friends: either the only good thing about professional development days is having a little break from the students, or that there's nothing good at all about it. It's boring, it's a waste of time, and for me I'd say it's actually detrimental to my mental health sometimes. 

We are stuck in rooms with other teachers, and lectured to like we're in a bachelor's level college class again. Sometimes there's an activity or some back and forth, but often that is even structured like how we structure our own classes with "parking lot" papers for questions and doing puzzle piece reading of articles that really don't have any new information. At least in my district, our topic is almost ALWAYS "engagement" or "data-driven practices". On the surface, those topics sound great, but they are just education buzzwords. And I know that the training companies that the district hires really try their best. But I have to ask: why are we hiring people who don't even know our district? They don't know our struggles or our students. And we should be making better choices. 

At least at my school, according to greatschools ratings, we are a 1/10, we are high poverty, high trauma, and high turnover. We've been in "turnaround" status with the state for over 8 years (I've lost count). I have, in my 5 years here, seen so many great teachers come and go that the students speak highly of. You wouldn't need to even talk about engagement if we could just keep the good teachers. 

So what do schools need right now? 

We need time to heal. COVID quarantine was the worst experience the schools have had... probably ever nation-wide. My school was bad enough before with engagement and attendance. And the whole energy of the school is just so much worse than when we shut down. And my district just keeps laying on the trauma. 

A year before the shutdown, we had a management company sign on to help us get out of turnaround. We were making improvements. One month before the shutdown, our admin was fired and the principal from our alternative school was hired. He was amazing. He made the teachers believe again. 

During shutdown, we could never have retained so many teachers if that staff change hadn't happened. I'm surprised as many stayed as they did. At least for arts teachers, it was a really depressing time to be teaching. What's even the purpose of being an instrumental music teacher with that format? 

During the summer before this school year started, the board hired a superintendent who was not part of our management company. She changed everything around when our admin had it almost put together for the year, and forced THEM into professional development sessions that did nothing for them. It only took away time from developing policies and systems that were starting to work. Things that were finally making teachers feel a little relief. 

This led to OUR professional development being haphazard and poorly planned. Almost all of the sessions had no point, or were labeled as engagement but were things we had definitely talked about in years prior. It always feels as though they're sending subtle hints that we're not interesting enough, we're not trying hard enough, we're not good enough teachers, and that's why we're failing. We're not enough. And I think it's from our higher-up admin. 

No one person or one set of admin can step into a broken system like this and be a hero. They won't fix it until they realize that they are not an island. We all have to work together and trust one another and some serious changes need to happen to fix that. Because after all the turnaround, the teachers no longer trust the admin in our building. The admin no longer trusts the district workers or the board. The admin doesn't trust the teachers because the teachers don't want to play by the rules. And because the adults are a mess, so are the kids. 

so what do we really need???

Professional development, if we HAVE to have it, should be focused on building community amongst teachers. We need time to cross our department lines and discuss best ideas, common issues, and come up with TEACHER-GUIDED solutions, but not during extra paid time. I hate this idea that professional development has to be bestowed upon us by someone who is paid to do it. It should be each other. We are all professionals. We all had to get a college degree, and because of the low pay a lot of people also have master's now if they've been teaching a while. We all have great information to share with each other. 

We need input from the counselors who see another side of our students and have information that they don't seem to share with us. We don't need nitty-gritty, in fact please don't ever tell me that so I can sleep at night, but we need to know that you spoke to student X after we asked, and let us know what the plan is currently to get them on track. Were they assessed for mental health resources? Were parents contacted? And what the heck should we do with them in the meantime if they're acting up or just doing nothing in our classes? 

On top of that, teachers need training on really setting boundaries and being their own person. We need training on how to keep work at work and home at home or we get burnt out and we quit. We need mental health supports in order to know how to process the secondary trauma we feel from hearing about kids who are suicidal or breaking up fights in the hallway, or being around kids who make us feel unsafe in any way. There are so many ways to experience trauma, and our kids have, collectively experienced ALL of them, and so teachers have experienced secondary trauma through them. Right now the only way we know how is to try to save them and then burn out, or become a stone wall and try not to even listen or notice what's happening with them. 

We need better PD. And it needs to stop being buzzwords and lectures, and things that we've all heard before. It needs to be about connection and healing. Especially right now. 
Or I'm pretty sure we're all headed towards quitting. I see my own friends dropping like flies from the teaching career. 

It's time for a shift. I don't know how, but something has to give. 

No comments:

Post a Comment